OCD can develop in children, too

SINGAPORE — Regular handwashing is an important part of personal hygiene. But what would you do if your child takes this everyday routine to the extreme?

Miss Anastasia Zhai was only 13 years old when she was diagnosed with obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD) two years ago. She would wash and scrub her hands every 20 minutes, not stopping even when her skin cracked and bled from the obsessive handwashing.

For Anastasia’s mother, Madam Faye Tan, it was the start of a two-year-long parenting nightmare.

Once cheerful and bubbly, the 46-year-old working mother’s daughter had become withdrawn and moody, often hiding in a corner of her room. She would also draw circles on paper repetitively.

“I’ll always remember that dark period in our lives. The whole thing occurred out of the blue and she became a totally different person,” said Mdm Tan.

One of the top three most common mental-health disorders in Singapore, OCD is a type of anxiety disorder characterised by obsessive and compulsive thoughts and behaviours.

About one in 33 adults in Singapore has had OCD at some point in his or her lifetime, based on a Singapore Mental Health Study conducted in 2010. The Institute of Mental Health’s (IMH) outpatient clinics see some 600 to 700 adults with the condition yearly.

WHEN OCD STRIKES IN CHILDHOOD

Pages

Excessive imagination leads to obsessive-compulsive disorder

People who confuse reality with imagination and lose contact with reality are more likely to develop obsessive-compulsive disorder, or OCD. A new study suggests that conflicts in reality are the key characteristics that could play a role in the severity of OCD.

The new finding, published in the Journal of Clinical Psychology, is the confirmation of the observations of a 2011 research conducted by Obsessive-Compulsive and Tic Disorder Studies Centre, or CETOCT. The 2011 study states that people who rely heavily on their imagination and have a strong tendency to dissociate from reality had more obsessive symptoms.

The new study confirms the previous observations through a population of  patients with OCD, said Frederick Aardema, co-director of the CETOCT and assistant professor in the University of Montreal’s Department of Psychiatry. Theories show that the development of OCD is not particularly affected by the content of thought that is involved, but by the way a person interprets the thoughts.

“While most people will dismiss an idea if they feel it has no meaning, people with OCD will say that if they think that way [there] must be a reason,” Aardema said.

For the new study, the researchers asked 75 people with OCD to complete questionnaires to assess inferential confusion, schizotypal personality, dissociative experiences, strength of obsessive beliefs and depressive and anxiety symptoms.

Inferential confusion is a reasoning process in which obsessive doubt takes hold, according to Stella-Marie Paradisis, a doctoral student in psychology at the University of Montreal and lead author of the study. She also described Schizotypical personality as the tendency to overrely on imagination, and associated with a person’s bizarre ideas, rigid belief, and lack of discernment.

A person with schizotypical personality is often convinced that what he or she hears on the news or read in the newspaper concerns him or her personally and directly. Lastly, Paradisis explained dissociation experiences as the loss of contact with reality and memory lapses in certain situations.

The results of the assessment show the significance of inferential confusion and dissociative experiences to the prediction of OCD. People with OCD are preoccupied by their obsession due to inferential confusion that there is a break with reality.

Researchers concluded that individuals with OCD no longer rely on their sensory perceptions or common sense but on their imagination. For example, if patients are afraid that their hands are contaminated with germs, they will wash them over and over again because they are convinced that their hands are dirty even though they are visibly clean, Aardema explained.

According to the study, schizotypal personality, obsessive beliefs and anxiety and depressive symptoms appear to be insignificant factors in the development of OCD symptoms. However, researchers found that these factors influence the severity of the disorder.

Contact the writer at feedback@ibtimes.com.au or tell us what you think below

Overreliance on imagination may be a sign of obsessive-compulsive disorder


IMAGE

IMAGE: Confusing reality with imagination and losing contact with reality are two key characteristics that could play a role in the development of obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). This is what we learn…
view more

Credit: scribbletaylor. CC BY NC 2.0

This news release is available in French.

Confusing reality with imagination and losing contact with reality are two key characteristics that could play a role in the development of obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). This is what we learn from a study conducted by researchers at the CIUSSS de l’Est-de-l’Île-de-Montréal (Institut universitaire en santé mentale de Montréal) and the University of Montreal, the results of which were published in the Journal of Clinical Psychology.

“In general, researchers agree on the diagnostic criteria of OCD. However, there is no consensus on the mechanisms underlying them,” said Frederick Aardema, co-director of the Obsessive-Compulsive and Tic Disorder Studies Centre (CETOCT).

Already in 2011, the CETOCT team had observed that people who rely heavily on their imagination and have a strong tendency to dissociate from reality had more obsessive symptoms. The aim of the study was to confirm these observations in a population with OCD.

“Theories about OCD stipulate that it is not the content of thought that is involved in the development of obsessions but the way these thoughts are interpreted by the person,” added Aardema, assistant professor in the University of Montreal’s Department of Psychiatry. “While most people will dismiss an idea if they feel it has no meaning, people with OCD will say that if they think that way they must be a reason”

Method

The researchers asked 75 people with OCD to complete questionnaires assessing inferential confusion, schizotypal personality, dissociative experiences, strength of obsessive beliefs, and depressive and anxiety symptoms.

“First, inferential confusion is a reasoning process in which obsessive doubt takes hold. Individuals make subjective connections between different elements,” explained Stella-Marie Paradisis, a doctoral student in psychology at the University of Montreal and lead author of the study. “For example, the person believes that the water in a municipal swimming pool is contaminated because chlorine has been put into it, so inevitably there are bacteria in the water. Second, schizotypical personality is characterized by bizarre ideas, rigid belief, lack of discernment, and a tendency to overrely on imagination. For example, individuals are convinced that what they hear on the news or read in the newspaper concerns them personally and directly. Finally, dissociation is characterized by loss of contact with reality and memory lapses in certain situations – a phenomenon that can be observed especially in people who display checking behaviour. Some people feel that they can behave so differently depending on the situation that they are two different people.”

Results

The results of the CETOCT team highlight the important role of inferential confusion and dissociative experiences, which are signs that best predict OCD symptoms. “It seems that people with OCD are so absorbed by their obsession due to inferential confusion that there is a break with reality,” explained Professor Aardema. “Specifically, we found that individuals no longer rely on their sensory perceptions or common sense but on their imagination. For example, they are afraid that their hands are contaminated with germs, so they wash them over and over again because they are convinced that their hands are dirty even though they are visibly clean,” concluded the researcher.

Other factors such as anxiety and depressive symptoms, schizotypal personality, and obsessive beliefs do not seem to play a significant role in the development of OCD symptoms but in the severity of the disorder.

###

About the authors

Frederick Aardema is a researcher at Institut universitaire en santé mentale de Montréal (CIUSSS de l’Est-de-l’Île-de-Montréal), co-director of the Obsessive-Compulsive and Tic Disorder Studies Centre (CETOCT), and assistant professor in the Department of Psychology at the University of Montreal.

Stella-Marie Pardisis is a doctoral student at Institut universitaire en santé mentale de Montréal (CIUSSS de l’Est-de-l’Île-de-Montréal) and the Deparment of Psychology at the University of Montreal

Kevin D. Wu is a researcher in the Department of Psychology at the University of Northern Illinois.

About the study

Source: Paradisis, S. M., Aardema, F., Wu, K. D. (2015). Schizotypal, Dissociative, and Imaginative Processes in a Clinical OCD Sample. J Clin Psychol. Epub ahead of print. The University of Montreal is officialy known as Université de Montréal.

OCD symptoms checklist

According to several studies and an important meta-analysis (Bloch, Landeros-Weisenberger, Rosario, Pittenger, Leckman,2008), OCD symptoms can be categorized into five areas:

1. symmetry

2. cleaning

3. hoarding

4. forbidden thoughts (e.g., aggression, religious)

5. checking.

10 things to know about compulsive hoarding

Clutter.JPG

You’re buying things a second time because you lost the first ones you purchased. You can’t fit your car in the garage because it’s jam-packed with junk that you just can’t bear to throw away. If this sounds like you, you probably aren’t a hoarder—particularly if all you need is a long weekend and a little help to clear up your clutter.

Hoarding is a serious mental illness that affects 2 to 5 percent of the population, according to the American Psychiatric Association. Not all people go to the extremes featured in hoarding reality shows, but if clutter is affecting your social life, job, family relationships, or personal safety, you could have a problem. Here’s what you need to know.

Hoarding starts with normal clutter
It’s one thing to always have a pile of mail on your kitchen counter or a messy bedroom closet (they’re never big enough). It’s another thing to store boxes in your oven.

“When you cross that line and go from using places that are supposed to be for storage, such as closets, to filling your bathtub and dining room table with boxes, you’re on your way to hoarding,” said Matt Paxton, extreme cleaning specialist and TV personality on Hoarders: Family Secrets.

Hoarders have good intentions
Hoarders have the best of intensions and the worst follow through, said Patrick McGrath, PhD, Chicago psychotherapist and former host of The Learning Channel’s Hoarding: Buried Alive. “They see a lawn mower on the side of the road and think, ‘Oh, I can fix that,’ forgetting they have 17 in their yard already. They’re always getting ready to do something but never get to it.”

RELATED: 12 Ways We Sabotage Our Mental Health

Hoarding is often triggered by a major loss
The death of a loved one, divorce, or other traumatic event—even a date gone horribly wrong—can trigger hoarding.

“The hoarded stuff doesn’t die, and it will never leave you,” McGrath said. “So hoarders are connected to their stuff by memories. It’s an emotional connection. Everything has meaning, so by tossing it out you’re disrespecting it and the person connected to it.”
This connection often makes it extremely upsetting for the hoarder to throw things out and let them go.

Hoarders suffer serious consequences
Filling a house with stuff makes for many health hazards.

“Fires and mold are problems, and injuries can occur when people trip and fall while making their way through little paths in their home they create,” McGrath said. “In some cases a service person can’t access a furnace when it dies because the hoarding takes up so much room.”

Hoarding also creates strained family ties when, for example, grandkids aren’t allowed to visit their hoarding grandparents.

“People don’t understand the appeal of the hoarded items as the hoarder does,” McGrath said.

RELATED: 10 Nervous Habits That Hurt Your Health

Hoarding starts in adolescence
Although hoarding usually doesn’t manifest fully until adulthood, the seeds of hoarding are typically planted in adolescence, said Gail Gross, PhD, a nationally recognized family and child development expert, author, and educator. The average age when symptoms first appear is 13, according to the APA.

“There may be a genetic link to hoarding,” Gross said.

In fact, a 2008 study published in the journal Genes, Brain and Behavior suggests that a certain gene may lend itself to a greater susceptibility to hoarding. Hoarding symptoms also tend to run in families, according to a 2015 study published in Depression and Anxiety.

Hoarding differs from collecting
Collectors usually keep their items displayed, organized, and even wrapped and sealed, McGrath said.”Hoarding is willy nilly all over the place. It also interferes with your life.”

A large collection of horse memorabilia, for example, that is displayed in a clean, organized way is not hoarding. But if the items start to pile up, become moldy and dirty, and end up being stashed in the bathtub, that’s hoarding, McGrath said. There’s no organization to the clutter, which is often stacked precariously or tossed into piles.

RELATED: Best and Worst Ways to Cope with Stress

Hoarding is its own mental illness
Initially thought of as a subset of obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), hoarding is now considered a separate affliction on its own, McGrath said. Known as “hoarding disorder,” hoarding affects a person’s ability to maintain relationships, hold down a job, and function normally in general. Hoarders are often indecisive, prone to procrastination and perfectionism, disorganized, and easily distracted, which can contribute to the overall severity of the hoarding.

Hoarders become socially isolated
If a loved one stops inviting you over to their home, they could be embarrassed by the clutter.

“They may meet you at the end of the driveway but not allow you to come inside,” Paxton said. “Sometimes you can look toward the top of the windows and see boxes and other items stacked up.”

There may be no place to sit or visit comfortably. In addition, children of hoarders often won’t bring home friends because the mess embarrasses them.

Hoarding is not about monetary value
It’s never about the monetary worth or value of the item itself, Paxton said. “It doesn’t matter what it’s worth, it’s about control. We’ve found everything from famous artwork to $18,000 in cash in a rat’s nest to piles of used diapers.”

On some level, hoarders believe that these items will serve them in the future, Gross said. “They feel less anxious and more comfortable by possessing them. In fact, just the thought of eliminating or clearing the clutter creates anxiety, stress, and dysfunction.”

Overcoming hoarding requires therapy
Aside from a temporarily cleaner home, hiring a crew to clear out a hoarder’s house will do nothing for the person in the long term. In fact, taking things away will only backfire.

“Many hoarders experience a subset of problems that tend to get worse over the years, such as alcohol and drug abuse or anxiety,” Gross said. “Cognitive behavioral therapy is most successful, especially when incorporated with medication if necessary.”

This approach enables hoarders to lower their stress and anxiety and eventually learn to let go of unneeded objects and clutter. “Through behavior modification and cognitive behavioral therapy, hoarders can give voice to their depression, stress, or anxiety while helping to find healthy ways to reduce their stress, relax, and self manage the hoarding,” Gross said.

RELATED: 10 Signs You Should See a Doctor for Depression

This article originally appeared on Health.com.

Understanding Body-Focused Repetitive Behaviors

To this day, Katie Koppel, a 23-year-old recent college graduate who lives in Boston, still remembers the exact moment she first pulled out her hair. She was a bored 7-year-old, sitting in front of the television. Mindlessly, her fingers wandered to her face and landed on her eyebrows.

“I pulled out half my eyebrow in a couple of hours,” Koppel recalls. “I just remember looking into the mirror and seeing what I had done, and not understanding what had just happened. I felt this tremendous sense of fear.”

Koppel’s pediatrician thought her hair loss might be caused by lupus. Her parents were stymied. Nobody thought to ask Koppel – who by then had begun shutting herself in closets for hours at a time, yanking at her face and scalp with swollen fingers – if she was pulling her hair out herself.

Eventually, Koppel’s mother did a Google search for “unusual forms of hair loss.” She discovered a clinical term for her daughter’s condition: trichotillomania.

Trichotillomania is a condition in which individuals feel the compulsive urge to tug out their body hair. Leg hair, scalp hair, arm hair and armpit hair are all fair game, as is facial hair, eyelashes, chest and pubic hair. However, Koppel and her mother would soon learn that trichotillomania falls under an even broader umbrella of little-understood disorders called body-focused repetitive behavior, or BFRBs. These are behaviors that involve compulsively damaging one’s physical appearance – picking at skin, pulling hair, biting nails and even chewing one’s lips or the inside of the cheeks.

But wait – doesn’t everyone pull their hair or pick their skin from time to time?

According to Dr. Nancy Keuthen, a professor of psychology at Harvard Medical School and co-director of the Trichotillomania Clinic at Massachusetts General Hospital, individuals with BFRBs “have tried repeatedly to decrease or stop. [Their behaviors] cause distress and impairment in functioning,” she says. “All of us do some skin picking or hair pulling, whether you’re going to admit it or not, but the people who come in for treatment are the people who are seeing significant tissue damage or hair loss.”

About 1 to 3 percent of the population is thought to have trichotillomania, and about 1 to 5 percent is thought to have a skin picking condition known as excoriation disorder. The people who have this clinical level of the diagnosis, Keuthen says, will often start picking or pulling around puberty – although they can also start earlier or later in life. Both men and women struggle with BFRBs, although women are more likely to seek treatment.

Patients with BFRBs might spend an hour or more a day picking, pulling, biting or thinking about it. They’ll constantly try to manage their urges – which might negatively affect their relationships, friendships, family functioning and focus at school or work.

There are also medical and cosmetic concerns. Those who pick at their skin might experience infections and scarring. Individuals who pull out their hair might find it difficult to grow back. In rare and extreme cases, people can pick down to the muscle or dig away at their nose so much that their septum collapses.

And, of course, like many psychological conditions, trichotillomania, excoriation disorder and other related behaviors are accompanied by stigma.

BFRBs are “disorders of isolation and of shame,” says Koppel, who wears a wig to hide her hair loss. “I think in a lot of ways that’s more damaging than any more physical or medical consequences could ever be. Every single person I know with trichotillomania has, at one point, felt like they were the only one who did this. They didn’t know it had a name, they didn’t know it was diagnosable. And people were reinforcing that shame by telling them [they] could stop if they wanted to.”

Men with trichotillomania often escape scrutiny by shaving their heads or beards. With women, who tend to have longer hair, it’s a little harder to hide. And those with excoriation disorders will often pick at areas covered by clothing or wear garments to conceal their marks.

So why do people pick and pull? Doctors are still trying to figure that out. Trichotillomania and excoriation disorder are both listed in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders; both are considered obsessive-compulsive spectrum disorders, though they’re unique from OCD. (Nail biting, lip chewing, nose picking and other behaviors aren’t yet listed; they aren’t as often reported, nor are they as widely studied.)

“OCD is really all anxiety-driven,” says Carol Mathews, a professor of psychiatry at the University of Florida. “You feel a sense of relief when you’ve acted on your compulsion, but you don’t feel a reward. With hair pulling, you feel a sense of relief, a sense of reward, if you got the right hair or you got that scab.”

Mathews adds that OCD is usually accompanied by obsessions – fears of contamination, or a thought that you might harm someone. Compulsions are in direct response to those thoughts. But rather than being triggered by thought, hair pulling and skin picking are driven by urges. “It’s a very physical act,” Mathews says. “There are mental compulsions that you can have with OCD, but it doesn’t have to be a physical compulsion.”

BFRBs feel different for everyone. Some people feel an increased sense of tension or anxiety before they pick or pull, and a feeling of relief after. Yet others pick or pull – almost in an absent-minded manner – when they’re understimulated or bored. And many individuals engage in both hair pulling and picking; Keuthen says that up to half of people with trichotillomania also have excoriation disorder. “They’re kind of kissing cousins,” she says.

Angela Hartlin, a 29-year-old from Dartmouth, Nova Scotia, who has excoriation disorder, finds she’s more prone to picking while dealing with stress.

Her skin picking “was personally driven by anxiety,” Hartlin says, who once picked at her skin for hours a day and has experienced both infections and scarring. “I found it calming. So calming down the anxiety is something I have to do as part of my self-care routine. You have to know your own specific triggers and counter them.”

Hartlin eventually recognized her triggers. But it took help from a professional therapist, who started working with Hartlin after she appeared on a television show to talk about her experience with excoriation disorder.

For years, Hartlin couldn’t find help. Both Hartlin and Koppel faced a common problem that many patients with BFRBs experience – a difficulty finding a medical provider who understands their conditions. Many physicians have little clinical understanding of BFRBs and aren’t trained to treat them. Or they’ll mistakenly diagnose excoriation disorder or trichotillomania as an unrelated skin or psychological disorder.

There are experts out there who treat BFRBs. But if you have a BFRB and don’t live near a major hospital, your best bet is to seek a therapist who specializes in cognitive behavioral therapy, says Dr. Jon Grant, a professor of psychiatry at the University of Chicago. They should be well versed in these behaviors and can hopefully tailor their approach to fit your needs.

Antidepressant medications like SSRIs, or selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, are often prescribed for individuals with BFRBs. But although they might help with anxiety and depression – which, in turn, might alleviate skin picking or hair pulling – Grant says they show little efficacy for treating conditions like trichotillomania and excoriation disorder. However, studies have indicated that a pharmaceutical drug and nutritional supplement called N-acetyl cysteine might reduce patients’ urges to pull or pick.

Even then, treatment is highly individualized for each patient. Some people might respond to cognitive behavioral therapy, which teaches patients to recognize their thoughts and behaviors and change them. Yet others might not be motivated enough to fully engage in a series of sessions. N-acetyl cysteine might yield improvements in one individual, but not another. Bottom line? What works for you might not work for someone else – and vice versa. For instance, Koppel has not found much success with cognitive behavioral therapy, but she did once stop pulling for six months after trying hypnotherapy. And Hartlin didn’t notice much of a difference with N-acetyl cysteine, but she greatly benefited from therapy.

Is remission possible? Experts and patients alike agree it is – although “remission” might not necessarily mean that you’ll never pick or pull again. Some people are able to stop completely. But you shouldn’t be too hard on yourself if you occasionally find your hand straying toward your face or scalp, Grant says. 

Hartlin agrees. “Recovery is possible, but you need to accept yourself and where you’re at with picking or pulling. Loving who you are will enhance your life,” Hartlin says. “I’m in a state of recovery now where I … still have urges, but I can emotionally work through them.”

Hartlin still occasionally finds herself picking – but after many years, she says she’s finally able to wear shorts for the first time. She also finds it rewarding to spread awareness of BFRBs; she’s formed support groups, and her memoir, “Forever Marked: A Dermatillomania Diary,” recounts her years of struggle.

And Koppel – who recently authored her own memoir – found her greatest source of solace through the Trichotillomania Learning Center, which was founded in 1991 to provide advocacy, awareness and support for individuals with trichotillomania. Since then, it has expanded to include those with other BFRBs. While Koppel isn’t in “remission” per se, she is actively seeking treatment. Most importantly, she’s no longer ashamed.

“What I really attribute my emotional healing to is the Trichotillomania Learning Center’s conferences,” Koppel says. “I finally realized for the first time that I wasn’t alone. It’s one thing to read an article on the Internet, but another to be surrounded by people in a room who are going through the same experiences you are. That really drove things home in a way nothing else could.”

Controlling Intrusive Thoughts – Suppress, Repress or Accept?

shutterstock_238867240shutterstock_238867240



The minds of those both with mental health problems and those without can be invaded by unwanted intrusive thoughts often on a daily basis. Finding the best strategy for when a nasty intrusive thought comes to mind is a challenge many of us share, and for some of us it can ultimately make the difference between happiness and despair.

Suppression of intrusive thoughts

Quite simply, as defined in a recent review paper:

“Thought suppression is a conscious process whereby an individual attempts not to think about something… Acts of thought suppression are, by definition, conscious and volitional attempts to push a thought from one’s mind”

With this in mind, try not to think about the grime under your toilet seat. Haha, gross but gotcha! It’s near impossible NOT to think about it—YUK! This is the problem with attempting to prevent thoughts. Both experience and research are in agreement that suppressed thoughts can rebound. By trying to suppress intrusive thoughts, you can actually think about it more rather than less.

In fact, research has gone so far as to say that suppression of intrusive thoughts can actually lead to them being hyper-accessible. This hyper-accessibility in turn makes any stimuli related to the thought hyper-salient. Basically, like the word toilet, anything related to the poorly suppressed thought becomes more noticeable. The final nail in the coffin is that these heightened intrusive thoughts and their triggers make it even harder to control related unwanted behaviours.

This is not good news for those with mental health problems, like obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD), depression, anxiety or addiction. For example, while almost all addicted smokers wishing to quit report attempting to suppress thoughts of smoking, multiple studies suggest this suppression actually increases thoughts of smoking, cravings and the act of smoking itself. Moreover, successful quitters were shown to use less thought suppression in day-to-day life than failed quitters.

Considering the sadly predictable aftermath of thought suppression’s rebound effect, it’s no surprise that people who frequently suppress thoughts are at higher risk of developing a wide range of psychopathologies. Thought suppression is certainly not a prime example of the easiest answer to a problem being the best one—it’s an awful solution! If you want to manage intrusive thoughts, don’t bother with suppressing your thoughts!

Repressive coping with intrusive thoughts

Wait, you might be thinking, I’m quite good at not thinking about stuff if I don’t want to. Well, you may be a “natural suppressor”, otherwise known as a repressor. Rather than actively trying and (likely counterproductively) suppressing a thought alone, repressors also intentionally avoid the negative intrusive thought. This often involves distracting attention elsewhere, and if need be, enhancing positive moods, dampening the thought suppression rebound effect.

Here’s what the authors of the review paper had to say:

“In general terms, repressive coping seems to be an effective short term strategy for exercising control over negative or threatening thoughts, though the longer term consequences of repressive coping do not seem to be adaptive, being associated with increased mortality and poorer health outcomes amongst various cohorts.”

The example given in the paper is that of heart attack patients receiving a psychological stress intervention. Poorer health was found for patients using repressive coping strategies than anxious patients, presumably because their problem avoiding strategies were foiled by the inherently problem-focused nature of interventions.

Moreover, this is likely related to reports of repressor’s superior self-deception abilities, involving unrealistic optimism and overly positive self-evaluation. This is reflected well in a study that showed that physiological signs of anxiety measured in the lab (like heart rate and muscle tension) are out of touch with how anxious repressors claim to feel.

Mindful management of intrusive thoughts

So how can we stop thinking certain intrusive thoughts without trying to stop thinking about them? One answer is mindfulness.

Mindfulness, i.e. non-judgemental present moment awareness, by definition and as proven through experimentation, is negatively correlated with thought suppression. In fact, the success of mindfulness practices in managing and reducing the occurrence of intrusive thoughts is partially mediated by inhibiting thought suppression. The goal is not to suppress or repress these unwanted thoughts as they arise, but to accept their place in your mind and make no effort to control, analyze or change them.

This is a lovely example of how the least obvious answer to a problem is sometimes the best one. For example, when comparing mindful management of intrusive smoking thoughts to suppression, only mindfulness had beneficial effects on reported nicotine dependence and emotional functioning over the course of the study.

Mindfulness trains a more effective way of dealing with and reducing intrusive thoughts, likely through enhancing executive control brain functions (willpower one could say). With mindfulness-based cognitive therapy (MBCT) for example, mindfulness-based acceptance and lack of judgement have been suggested to facilitate both reductions in intrusive thoughts, as well as reframing thoughts and changing related behaviors. Ultimately, mindfulness creates the space for the cognitive restructuring of how we think and behave, perfect for the control of intrusive thoughts.

Conclusions

What can we say with confidence from scientific findings? Suppression alone is a big fat no no; repression may provide a patch-up job allowing you to happily go about your day relatively unscathed, although may come with a catch; while mindful management of thoughts may provide the fastest route to blasting those intrusive thoughts from mind with no negative ramifications reported thus far.

References

Bowen S, Witkiewitz K, Dillworth TM, Chawla N, Simpson TL, Ostafin BD, Larimer ME, Blume AW, Parks GA, Marlatt GA (2006). Mindfulness meditation and substance use in an incarcerated population. Psychology of addictive behaviors : journal of the Society of Psychologists in Addictive Behaviors, 20 (3), 343-7 PMID: 16938074

Erskine JA, Georgiou GJ, Kvavilashvili L (2010). I suppress, therefore I smoke: effects of thought suppression on smoking behavior. Psychological science, 21 (9), 1225-30 PMID: 20660892

Frasure-Smith N, Lespérance F, Gravel G, Masson A, Juneau M, Bourassa MG (2002). Long-term survival differences among low-anxious, high-anxious and repressive copers enrolled in the Montreal heart attack readjustment trial. Psychosomatic medicine, 64 (4), 571-9 PMID: 12140346

Moss, A., Erskine, J., Albery, I., Allen, J., Georgiou, G. (2015). To suppress, or not to suppress? That is repression: Controlling intrusive thoughts in addictive behaviour Addictive Behaviors, 44, 65-70 DOI: 10.1016/j.addbeh.2015.01.029

Myers LB, Brewin CR (1996). Illusions of well-being and the repressive coping style. The British journal of social psychology / the British Psychological Society, 35 ( Pt 4), 443-57 PMID: 8997699

Salkovskis PM, Reynolds M (1994). Thought suppression and smoking cessation. Behaviour research and therapy, 32 (2), 193-201 PMID: 8155058

Shikatani B, Antony MM, Kuo JR, Cassin SE (2014). The impact of cognitive restructuring and mindfulness strategies on postevent processing and affect in social anxiety disorder. Journal of anxiety disorders, 28 (6), 570-9 PMID: 24983798

Toll BA, Sobell MB, Wagner EF, Sobell LC (2001). The relationship between thought suppression and smoking cessation. Addictive behaviors, 26 (4), 509-15 PMID: 11456074

Weinberger DA, Schwartz GE, Davidson RJ (1979). Low-anxious, high-anxious, and repressive coping styles: psychometric patterns and behavioral and physiological responses to stress. Journal of abnormal psychology, 88 (4), 369-80 PMID: 479459

Wells A, Roussis P (2014). Refraining from intrusive thoughts is strategy dependent: a comment on Sugiura, et al. And a preliminary informal test of detached mindfulness, acceptance, and other strategies. Psychological reports, 115 (2), 541-4 PMID: 25243365

Image via Sergey Nivens / Shutterstock.



Further Reading

Aarica Marsh: Obsessing over OCD

However, as I began to really listen to the lyrics, I couldn’t help but fall in love with the song.

It’s no secret that my family is full of people with mental health issues similar to those that Eminem suffers from. My dad and his three siblings all have severe anxiety and depression, passing along these wonderful traits to nearly all of their offspring. Their dad, my late grandfather, took several medications most of his life for bipolar disorder, a disease that we unfortunately discovered was passed along to my youngest brother when he was nine years old.

Despite recognizing the plethora of mental health problems existing within the Marsh DNA, I never quite recognized the other anxiety-associated issues affecting my family until I heard Eminem rapping about them on the radio.

In the second verse of “The Monster,” the self-proclaimed Rap God admits to experiencing obsessive-compulsive disorder alongside other mental health issues. Other than one episode of “Grey’s Anatomy” in which Dr. Miranda Bailey is forced to stop performing surgery to deal with her problematic OCD, it was the first time I had actually heard someone in popular culture talk about experiencing obsessive-compulsive symptoms.

While the Detroit-based artist was revealing his problems with OCD, the rest of the world seemed to remain silent. According to an article from Medical Daily, “Because there isn’t much public awareness of OCD, (it makes) it even harder for people to cope and find help for their condition.”

Is OCD another case of don’t ask, don’t tell?

According to the National Institute of Health, only 2.2 million American adults, about 1 percent of the population, have been diagnosed with OCD. Yet, a 2014 study found that 94 percent of people experience intrusive, unwanted thoughts associated with OCD in their daily lives. The disorder exists on a spectrum, with most affected individuals being able to rationally cope with their intrusive thoughts.

Unfortunately, the 1 percent of our population who have been diagnosed OCD suffer from severe symptoms that interfere with their lives on a daily basis. There are many classifications of OCD: washers, checkers, doubters and sinners, hoarders, counters and arrangers. The thoughts are irrational, may be genetic and often occur simultaneously with other mental health issues, especially anxiety.

Reading more about OCD made me realize how often I, and several members of my family, perform OCD-like behaviors. I check to make sure my keys are in my pocket three times before shutting my car door, I’m super-organized at work and am irritated when other employees put things in the wrong place (it’s not just because my boss wants me to be). I can’t stand when my housemates use my toothpaste because they don’t use it the right way.

I asked my bipolar brother if he ever experiences similar behaviors; his keys have to be a certain way in the ignition, he walks around the house at night making sure all of the doors are locked, his phone always goes in a certain pocket.

When I was younger, watching my dad perform obsessive-compulsive behaviors — such as walking down three stairs, back up them and then down — I thought he was superstitious. Today, I realize these behaviors are most likely an effect of the anxiety and depression he suffers from.

Yet, psychologists warn, “Just because you have obsessive thoughts or perform compulsive behaviors does NOT mean that you have obsessive-compulsive disorder.”

So, maybe we’re not technically OCD.

Our behaviors don’t necessarily disrupt the way we live our lives, yet sometimes they’re still problematic. Listening to Eminem has assured me that I am not alone and has helped me finally recognize the way I do things, and why I do the “weird” things that I do. Acceptance is always the first step.

Eminem said it best: “I am nuts for real, but I’m okay with that.”

Aarica Marsh can be reached at aaricama@umich.edu.

Phrase, ‘You are so OCD,’ diminishes seriousness of disease

Read more from Rachel Velishek

Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD) is the last topic in my five-part series on anxiety.

OCD is a frequently used term, but it is used generally as an insult such as “You are so OCD.”

It is important for me to clarify that OCD is not having a preference where you place the box of tissues or how you arrange a series of photos. 

According to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM), which is the gold standard for my field, OCD is when an individual displays either obsessions or compulsions or maybe even both. 

So, what is an obsession? According to the DSM, obsessions are defined as:

 1. Recurrent and persistent thoughts, urges or impulses that are experienced, at some time during the disturbance, as intrusive and unwanted, and that in most individuals cause marked anxiety or distress.

2.  The individual attempts to ignore or suppress such thoughts, urges or images, or to neutralize them with some other thought or action (i.e., by performing a compulsion)

Translation:  Frequent, upsetting thoughts that get in the way of a person’s life.

Compulsions are defined by both:

1.       Repetitive behaviors (e.g., hand-washing, ordering, checking) or mental acts (e.g., praying, counting, repeating words silently) that the individual feels driven to perform in response to an obsession or according to rules that must be applied rigidly.

2.        The behaviors or mental acts are aimed at preventing or reducing anxiety or distress, or preventing some dreaded event or situation; however, these behaviors or mental acts are not connected in a realistic way with what they are designed to neutralize or prevent, or are clearly excessive.

Translation:  The uncontrollable urge to repeat certain rituals or behaviors. The behaviors cannot be controlled, and more often than not, the rituals actually control the individual.

It is important to consider the impact that obsessive and compulsive behaviors have on an individual’s level of functioning. They are generally time-consuming, taking up more than one hour per day of an individual’s time, thought, energy or they have to cause a significant level of distress or impairment in social, occupational or other important and necessary levels of functioning.

An individual with OCD does not get pleasure when performing the behaviors or rituals, but will receive a brief relief from the anxiety the thoughts causes.

Healthy people also have habits or rituals such as checking that the stove is off, curling iron is unplugged all before leaving the house.

The difference for individuals with OCD is that they perform the rituals even though it has a significant impact on their daily life and the repetition is distressing.

It is more common for adults to recognize the compulsive behavior as irrational and senseless, more difficult for children to learn and recognize that the behavior is out of the ordinary.

Like other mental health disorders, it is important to rule out any substance use or abuse as contributing factor into the behavior.

Stress, illness, parenting, family accommodations do not cause OCD, however these conditions may contribute to an individual’s level of stress and if an individual has a history of OCD in the family they are more likely to display the symptoms.

 

‘OCD get out of me’: Family helps boy cope with perfectionist disorder

Sean Curzan, now 12, vividly remembers the fourth grade.

He already had numerous tics — sudden, repetitive movements or sounds, which were difficult for him to control. Sean would flip his hair, bounce his leg, roll his eyes, and twitch his nose.

When he turned 10, it was no longer just tics that interfered with his life; his school work started to become especially difficult.

“Imperfections are my triggers,” Sean told TODAY.com. “I was not accomplishing my work. I spent hours trying to catch up and I would get upset if something wasn’t just right.”

Once Sean’s struggles in school started to intensify his parents took him to a doctor where he was diagnosed with Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD). OCD is defined by experts as the recurrence of distressing thoughts or images that produce extreme anxiety.

MORE: Worry about worrying: What it’s like to grow up with OCD

In order to dismiss the thoughts and images, individuals with the disorder feel compelled to engage in repetitive and compulsive behaviors that ultimately interfere with their daily lives. Specifically, Sean suffers from perfectionist OCD.

“Sean is a very smart kid and suddenly he couldn’t complete his assignments…he would spend hours looking up words in a thesaurus and he would compare them to make sure he found the right word and that it sounded just right,” Sean’s father, Mark Curzan explained. By day, Curzan is an orthopedic surgeon.

Sean’s mother, Tracy who is an Emergency Room physician, adds “If he got a 99 instead of a 100 he would get angry.”

Curzan Family

Sean’s OCD got worse and worse.

His parents really knew something was wrong after Sean wrote a 24-page biography on John Glenn — the first American to orbit the Earth. The teacher had only requested a two page paper. Tracy remembers the teacher giving Sean an A+ without even reading the biography.

RELATED: An app for those with OCD

Sean’s parents frantically tried to find a treatment option that worked for him.

He did not respond well to the typical, first line of OCD treatment, which is a type of cognitive behavioral therapy called Exposure Response Prevention therapy (ERP). Sean says that ERP was too tough for him, too much of an exposure. ERP gradually conditions patients to confront the triggers of their obsessive behavior for increasingly long periods of time, without acting upon them.

“While ERP usually works better than medications for treating OCD, drug treatment and ERP together work best in severe cases,” explains Eric Storch, PhD, expert in adolescent and teen OCD at the University of South Florida.

In Sean’s case, ERP did not work so he was placed on a regimen of drug therapy with selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs), which are types of antidepressants. SSRIs are viewed as all equally effective in treating OCD by doctors, but individual patients often respond better to one than another, and it takes some trial and error to determine which one is best.

RELATED: What doggy tail-chasing may reveal about our own OCD

For Sean, this trial and error almost cost him his life.

“About one year ago we found Sean on the roof of our home about to jump,” Tracy says.

Sean’s father explains that approximately 4% of people on SSRIs have suicide ideation and Sean was in that 4%. “He was one of them,” he says. “It was surreal seeing him spiral….I had to pinch myself.”

“We weren’t sure Sean would make it to his 12th birthday. Things had gotten so bad,” Tracy said.

Sean’s younger sister, Claire, who is like a caretaker to him adds, “I saw him on the roof and my mom told me to go downstairs. It is scary to know your brother is having these thoughts as a kid…I didn’t know what was going on. No one told me anything.”

Curzan Family

Right before the incident on the roof, Sean was switched to a new regimen of SSRIs by his doctor. The previous regimen was helping him, but not enough so it was time for a new therapy.

Thinking back on that horrific day, Sean says, “My mind just freaked out. I didn’t want to live like this. I think I freaked because the medications just weren’t working and I was back to square one; I was re-exposed to all of my triggers. I had been feeling better and then this new course of treatment didn’t do anything.”

Sean went into intensive therapy after his suicide attempt. He says that being in a hospital really gave him the motivation he needed for therapy.

One of Tracy’s biggest takeaways from the incident was that people must be engaged earlier on. “It took a hospitalization, my son almost jumping off the roof for him to really start to get the help and the attention he needed,” she says.

Though Sean was able to get a relatively quick diagnosis of OCD when he initially displayed symptoms, it took many months for him to finally get the right course of treatment.

RELATED: One mother’s battle to save her son from OCD

“One of my goals is to disseminate that there are good treatments available. It is a tragedy so few kids have access to treatments,” explains Lisa Coyne, PhD, program director at the Child and Adolescent OCD Institute at McLean Hospital. “OCD does not need to get that bad in a kid. There is care, we can do this and as doctors in this field we need to raise more awareness.”

For starters, people need to know that OCD starts in childhood. And, according to Dr. Storch, as many as 80% of people with OCD symptoms experience onset during childhood.

Since the roof incident, Tracy says that she and Mark have seen great progress in Sean. “He is doing awesome. We see him smile now,” she says. And Claire adds, “We see the light at the end of the tunnel. Sean seems a lot happier.”

Experts explain that OCD is a family affair and that it is essential to include family during therapy. “OCD treatment is not a style of treatment where you just drop off your kid and pick them up later. It is a family problem and all members of the family need to be engaged,” Dr. Storch says.

For the Curzan family, this couldn’t be more true.

“This is a family experience. We are doing this as a team,” Mark says.

Mark and Tracy brought the whole family to the International OCD Conference in Boston, MA this year knowing that it would be beneficial for Sean, Claire and their youngest daughter, Kate, to see other kids who have OCD as well.

On opening night of the conference, the three kids even rapped at orientation singing a song they wrote titled, ‘OCD Get Out of Me.’

Roberto Farren

To the Curzan family, the OCD Conference wrapped up a very tough year and they are hopeful knowing that Sean is doing well, getting better and better by the day.

“My OCD will always linger, but I am learning to live with it,” Sean explains.

“I have grown over the last year,” Sean says. “The word perfect has a new meaning. It means to enjoy and to do something to the best of your ability. It doesn’t hold me back like it used to.”

More video

Ask JJ: Sleep Supplements

Dear JJ: Many nights I struggle to fall asleep. I’ve seen a wide variety of over-the-counter natural sleep aids. Can you tell me which ones are most effective?

I’ve written about seven fat-regulating hormones that can become out of whack with sleep loss. One study found even a partial night of sleep deprivation could make you more insulin resistant, increasing your risk for obesity and Type 2 diabetes.

I could go on (this chart elucidates sleep deprivation’s wide-ranging devastation), but you understand how critical getting seven to nine hours of quality, uninterrupted sleep every night can become for fat loss and optimal health.

Manufacturers understand our epidemic sleep struggle. That’s why any drugstore or health-minded grocery offers a wide array of natural sleep aids. How do you choose the best one? Based on research coupled with three decades of working with clients, these are the natural sleep aids I find most effective.

Melatonin
This hormone helps control circadian (day/night) rhythms. Melatonin production, therefore, should peak at night for quality sleep. As we age, our bodies make less melatonin, which might explain why we also have more sleep difficulties.

If you struggle to drift off, supplementing might help. “Melatonin supplements can also be a great way to break the cycle of insomnia, deal with jet lag, or adjust to life as a shift worker,” says Dr. Sanjeev Kothare.

One meta-analysis about sleep disorders concluded melatonin supplementation “decreases sleep onset latency, increases total sleep time and improves overall sleep quality.”

Ideally, you should take supplemental melatonin bout 30 minutes before you want to fall asleep. While supplements contain different amounts, studies suggest the ideal dose is 3 mg.

Inositol
Many healthcare experts use this little-known member of the B-vitamin family to promote more restful sleep at night and create a more even-tempered mood during the day.

“Inositol is ‘nature’s sleeping pill,'” writes Dr. Jonny Bowden in The Most Effective Natural Cures on Earth. “Taken before bedtime, it can significantly improve sleep quality. People who take it report a general relaxed feeling akin to having a few calming ‘sleepy-time’ teas.”

Supplementing with inositol promotes calmness, and studies show it can ameliorate a wide range of mental health disorders including depression and anxiety, panic disorder, and obsessive-compulsive behavior.

Inositol supplements come in capsules or powder. For insomnia, Bowden recommends two grams of powdered inositol with water before bed. For difficulty falling or staying asleep, I find smaller doses (say, 500 mg) combined with other sleep-aiding nutrients like melatonin work well.

5-HTP
5-hydoxytrytophan (5-HTP) is synthesized from the amino acid tryptophan and eventually converted to serotonin, your feel-good neurotransmitter.

Compared with supplemental tryptophan, researchers believe supplementing with 5-HTP can better replenish serotonin levels because it is only one metabolic step away from serotonin and has an easier time crossing the blood-brain barrier.

“5-HTP dietary supplements help raise serotonin levels in the brain,” write researchers from the University of Maryland Medical Center. “Since serotonin helps regulate mood and behavior, 5-HTP may have a positive effect on sleep, mood, anxiety, appetite, and pain sensation.”

According to Bowden, because 5-HTP increases serotonin, it “has a calming, relaxing effect on brain chemistry. [A]t night, serotonin converts into melatonin, which is important for a great night’s sleep.”

One study found people who supplemented with 5-HTP fell asleep faster and slept more deeply than those who took a placebo.

While people with insomnia and other sleep disorders might benefit from higher doses, the University of Maryland Medical Center recommends 50 mg of 5-HTP one to three times a day for general use.

Worth noting: Because it serves as the cofactor to convert 5-HTP to serotonin, look for a 5-HTP supplement that also contains vitamin B6.

L-Theanine
Now you know why that afternoon green tea helps you chill out. Studies show L-theanine, an amino acid in this popular beverage, can reduce stress.

“Theanine works by increasing the production of GABA in the brain,” writes Dr. Natasha Turner. “Similar to the effects of meditation, it also stimulates alpha brainwaves naturally associated with deep states of relaxation and enhanced mental clarity.”

That deep relaxation can also help you drift into slumber: Studies show supplementing with 200 mg of L-theanine before bed could improve your sleep quality.

Your turn: If you’ve ever used sleep supplements, which one do you find works best to help you fall or stay asleep? Share yours below, and keep those great questions coming at AskJJ@jjvirgin.com.

Additional References
Jonny Bowden, The Most Effective Natural Cures on Earth, (Massachusetts: Fair Wind, 2008).